Gumperz 1968 how to define speech community language is the most powerful. The concept of speech community has a long and chequered history in. The work of john gumperz 1968, 1972a, b revived the concept of the speech community by considering it a social construct. Gumperz and levinson break this book into four parts, separately prefacing each genre of potential languagethought influence. His research on the languages of india, on codeswitching in norway, and on conversational interaction, has benefitted the study of sociolinguistics, discourse analysis, linguistic anthropology, and urban. Unlike other sign systems, the verbal system can, through the minute refinement of. View notes anth 4060 the speech community from anth 4060 at louisiana state university. In fishmans description, he touches on the ideas of social norms similar to gumperz. For gumperz it is the verbal repertoire, including vernac ular, dialects, argots, and jargons in the total. This is something which is difficult to define precisely. It is inescapable, yet there is remarkably little agreement or theoretical discussion of the.
At the local level there are the village dialects, which vary from village to. Li wei is professor of applied linguistics in the department of speech, and. The speech community spcom, a core concept in empirical linguistics, is the intersection of many principal problems in sociolinguistic theory and method. A definition of speech community in sociolinguistics. Anth 4060 the speech community the speech community john. Gumperz university of california, berkeley a lthough inquiry into the relationship between language and culture has grown considerably in recent years, most modern american work in this field. This essay will touch on the basis of multiple aspects of a speech community depending on their similarities and differences as well as how the concepts of these speech communities relate to such articles written by heller and jackson. Other definitions of speech community a speech community is a group of people who interact by means of speech.
All chapters descend from a wennergren foundation international symposium at ocho rios, jamaica, rethinking linguistic relativity, organized by john gumperz in 1991 gumperz and levinson 1992. The present paper will therefore employ the term linguistic community by. A distinction will be made between speech community as gumperz uses the term and talk community. Gumperz although not all communication is linguistic, language is by far the most powerful and versatile medium of communication. International encyclopedia of the social sciences 9. We will define linguistic community as a social group which may be either monolingual or multilingual, held together by frequency of social interaction patterns and set off from the surrounding areas by weaknesses in the lines of. Subsequently he served as a member of a cornell university team of social scientists carrying out a community study project in a north indian village. In contrast to speech community, a talk community emphasizes the substantive organization of common speech in use.
But we know from our discussions that this is a lots of variation exists within a group of speakers. It is such considerations as these which lead gumperz p. Communicative competence in educational perspective. By overextending the concept in this way gumperz basic requirement that the community be united. Speech variation and the study of indian civilization1 john j. Aug 05, 2015 linguistic communities may consist of small groups bound together by facetoface contact or may cover large regions. Unlike other sign systems, the verbal system can, through the minute refinement of its grammatical and semantic structure, be made to refer to a wide. Labov in nyc, gumperz in india, they reflect concerns of each researcher multilingualism for. The ethnography of communication is an approach to language research which has its origin in the development of a view in anthropology that culture to a large extent is expressed through language and of the view in linguistics that language is a system of. A group or community should be defined not only by what it is but also what is not. Sep 01, 2019 a speech community came to be understood as. Members of a speech community like lake convent speak talk differently, depending on the topics of conversation. In the small market centers, a form of speech is current which avoids.
Gumperz was, for most of his career, a professor at the university of california, berkeley. This possibility is explicitly recognised in the definition given by gumperz. Nov 23, 2010 gumperz, dorian, fishman, labov, hymes, and corder helped define a speech community. Members of a speech community like lake convent speak.
Sociolinguistics analyzes variation in discourse within a particular speech community, and it studies how that variation affects the unfolding of meaning in interaction and correlates with the social order of the community. Gumperz, 1977 defined codeswitching as the juxtaposition of passages of speech belonging to two different. Linguists like john gumperz pioneered research in how personal interaction can influence ways of speaking and interpreting, while noam chomsky studied how people interpret. The concept of speech community does not simply focus on groups that speak. Within the field, labovs 1966 definition has been repeatedly attacked, often by researchers with similar methodological and analytical predilections.
Anth 4060 the speech community the speech community john j. Gumperz extends the four maxims associated with grices cooperative principle grice, 1975 by identifying specific discourse strategies used to comply with the unstated maxims and, unlike grice, notes the existence of different standards for acceptable behavior depending upon the speech community. Since a discourse community may have its membership assigned both on the basis of speech or of writing, it follows that the concept of discourse community needs to be both mediumneutral and unconstrained by space and time. A speech community is a group of people who do not necessarily share the same language, but share a set of norms and rules for the use of language. Jul 07, 2019 the concept of speech as a means of identifying with a community first emerged in 1960s academia alongside other new fields of research like ethnic and gender studies. Their goal, as ours remains today, was to understand the.
Gumperz the speech community free download as pdf file. Gumperz university of california, berkeley a lthough inquiry into the relationship between language and culture has grown considerably in recent years, most modern american work in this field so far operates with unit languages and cultural isolates. A speech community is a group of people who share a set. He also writes that new york city is a single speech community because it is united by a common evaluation of the same variables 1966. Although not all communication is linguistic, language is by far the most powerful and versatile medium of. Fishman defines the speech community as a speech community is one, all of whose members share at least a single speech variety and the norms for its appropriate use 1971.
A social group which may be either monolingual or multilingual, held together by frequency of social interaction and set off from the surrounding areas by weaknesses in the lines of communication lots of models of the speech community and variation in it. Communicative practices are actions, and conversational inferences are made by human agents, acting in the real world. The boundaries between speech communities are essentially social rather than linguistic. Dialect differences and social stratification in a north. Our speech communities, whatever they are, exist in a real world. Codeswitching in bilingual speech has been studied and classified under various linguistic and social theories including language mixing, borrowing, calquing, and codeswitching pfaff, 1979.
India, it is convenient to distinguish three forms of speech gumperz 1957. Through his own qualitatively oriented work and his collaboration with charles ferguson on multilingualism in south asia, john gumperz criticized the notion of language as used by linguists, and introduced the notions of variety, repertoire, and linguistic community or speech community. Furthermore, from the point of view of social function, the distinction between bilingualism and bidialectalism is often not a significant one martinet 1954. At cornell university gumperz was invited to take over the hindi language training program. John gumperz work 1968, 1972, 1982 on speech community defined the social.
The ethnography of communication is an approach to language research which has its origin in the development of a view in anthropology that culture to a large extent is expressed through language and of the view in linguistics that language is a system of cultural behaviors hymes, 1974. Gumperz al ri te although not all communication is linguistic, ma most groups of any permanence, be they language is by far the most powerful and ver small bands bounded by facetoface contact, satile medium of communication. The adoption of the concept of the speech community as a unit of linguistic analysis emerged in the 1960s. A group of people who use the same set of speech signals is a speechcommunity 1933. John gumperz described how dialectologists had taken issue with the dominant approach in historical linguistics that saw linguistic communities as homogeneous. Obafemi awolowo university, ileife, nigeria abstract this article is the report of an investigation into the types of languages acquired at different periods in the lives of members of the education elite in a speech community. From the outset, ethnographically oriented definitions of speech community have declared their own tentativeness and dependance on the level of abstraction we wish to achieve gumperz 1962. Speech variation and the study of indian civilization. Although not all communication is linguistic, language is by far the most powerful and ver satile medium of. Speakers choose among this arsenal in accordance with the meanings they wish to convey gumperz 1964. In a next step, the social structure of the village is outlined. This community may be comprised of professionals familiar with language linguistics, etymologies, etc. The notion of verbal repertoire is linked to a particular speech community and contains all the accepted ways of formulating messages. Sociolinguists embrace john gumperz definition of a speech community as a.
Then enter the name part gumperz 1982 suggests that linguists look at codeswitching as a discourse mode, or a communicative option which is available to a bilingual member of a speech community on much the same basis as switching between styles or dialects is an option for the monolingual speaker. In gumperz 1958, phonetic and phonological variables in the village speech are identified in a way that is reminiscent of his phd thesis. Professor gumperz here synthesizes fundamental research on communication from a wide variety of disciplines linguistics, sociolinguistics, anthropology and nonverbal communication and develops an original and broadly based theory of conversational inference which shows how verbal communication can serve either between individuals of. Now gumperz defines a speech community as any human aggregate characterized by regular and frequent interaction by means of a shared body of verbal signs and set of from similar aggregates by significant differences in language use 219.
Speech communities are central to our understanding of how language and interactions occur in societies around the world and in this book readers will find an overview of the main concepts and critical arguments surrounding how language and communication styles distinguish and identify groups. Gumperz s own approach has been called interactional sociolinguistics. In the same years, dell hymes launched a call for a. Codeswitching behavior in antonito, co and phoenix, az a. Chomskys formal linguistics notion of an ideal speech community.
This was a significant advance over earlier definitions, since what was shared by. The african american speech community which labov had seen as defined by the shared norms of aave, was shown to be an illusion, as ideological disagreements about the status of aave among different groups of speakers attracted public attention. John gumperz described how dialectologists had taken issue with the dominant approach in historical linguistics that saw linguistic communities as homogeneous and localized entities in a way that allowed for drawing neat tree diagrams based on the. Gumperz 1968 how to define speech community language is. A speech community is a group that decides how language will be used. The defining characteristics of a discourse community might be 1 communality of interest, 2. To look at talk as it occurs in speech events is to look at communicative practices.
1693 402 1028 903 147 1500 394 167 1456 764 1041 831 1193 191 912 120 1331 1706 826 1632